Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Geary Johansen's avatar

Recently, through tinkering around with AI, I came across an interesting piece of social psychology from yesteryear. It's called the Power Distance Index (PDI) created by Geert Hofstede.

It was one of those lightbulb moments, and certainly explains the 'two movies, one screen' hugely varying experiences of British people in interacting with migrants. If you are a police officer, a social worker, local government worker, or even just a university graduate with a few obvious signs of higher social status, then it's highly likely that your experiences with migrants will have been generally positive, because people from non-Western cultures have much higher PDIs which indicates they will be deferential and excessively polite to anyone they perceive as having high social status.

If however, you are a cleaner, a hotel worker, a binman, or from any number of blue collar/working class backgrounds, then it's highly likely your experiences with migrants will have been more negative, because people from high PDI cultures are more dismissive, rude and condescending to those they perceive to be lower status.

This also holds true for foreign students in university environments. Western university students are no less status conscious and status enforcing than anyone else in Western cultures, but when it comes to foreign students, preparations for tertiary education will mean they are at least partially acculturated to Western values, with a higher degree of egalitarianism than normal for most people from their culture. People whose experiences stem mainly from interacting with tertiary educated people from outside the West aren't getting a full picture of the reality experienced by less privileged citizens.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?